Analysis: Why Renesas is creating mobile IC spinoff
Renesas Electronics’ decision to spin out its mobile semiconductor products into a separate subsidiary is motivated not only by the differences between the markets for microcontrollers and baseband chips, but also to help protect Renesas’ power amplifier business. SAN FRANCISCO—Renesas Electronics Corp. is spinning out its mobile semiconductor into a wholly owned subsidiary because of the markets formicrocontrollers and modem chips are worlds apart, and because executives want to improve the chances of its power amplifiers being designed into reference designs from other baseband suppliers, according to executives and market analysts.
Renesas, the leading vendor of microcontrollers and the third lagest chip company by revenue, said last week it would spin off its mobile chip unit into a new subsidiary, Renesas Mobile Corp., effective Dec. 1. The products being spun out into the new subsidiary include the company’s Mobile Multimedia SoC Business Division and most of the wireless modem business that formerly belonged to Nokia Corp., which Renesas is set to acquire by Nov. 30.
The spinout announcement caught some people off guard because Renesas executives have spoken about the modem chip technology being critical to the company’s future success, and because the acquisition was widely hailed as a bold and aggressive move.
Will Strauss, principal analyst at Forward Concepts Inc., applauded the spinout announcement. Setting up the wireless products in a different business makes sense because the market for wireless chips is such a dramatically different market than Renesas’ core microcontroller business, Straus said. Whereas many microcontrollers are marketed for years to industrial, automotive and other markets, wireless technology is changing so fast that products can become obsolete within a year, he said.
“It’s a good move,” said Strauss, adding that he was also impressed with the speed of Renesas’ operational execution.
Dan Mahoney, president and CEO of Renesas’ U.S. unit, Renesas Electronics America Inc., said the primary reasons for the move were the fast-moving nature of the mobile communications market and the fact that the new unit has the potential to help Renesas with its top-line objective of growing sales outside of Japan. Renesas’ corporate strategy includes a clear directive to by 2012 increase revenue from outside of the Japanese market to 60 percent of the company’s total from 45 percent at the time of the merger between NEC Electronics and Renesas Technology which formed the company.
But a second, equally compelling reason for the move, according to Mahoney is that Renesas’ important power amplifier business depends on the company having its power amplifiers incorporated into reference designs created by baseband chip vendors such as Qualcomm Inc. These suppliers might feel more comfortable sharing technical information with Renesas with the “firewall” of Renesas’ own baseband chip business residing in a separate company, Mahoney said.
Strauss said the strategy makes sense. Baseband suppliers would feel more comfortable doing business with Renesas because it will have “arm’s length” separation from its baseband business.
Linley Gwennap, principal analyst of The Linley Group, said baseband suppliers like Qualcomm would probably try to avoid incorporating Renesas’ parts in their reference design if they can even with the spinout because they would still view Renesas as a baseband competitor.
Gwennap described the spinout as more of a marketing move, with a goal of giving more visibility and branding for Renesas’ mobile products. While U.S. and European companies typically spin out businesses into subsidiaries largely in preparation to sell them, Japanese companies are structured differently and tend to have a lot of subsidiaries that are wholly owned, he said.
Gwennap said Renesas is making some aggressive moves, particularly for a Japanese company, because Japanese companies in general are not known for marketing. “They are making some moves that you wouldn’t expect from a Japanese company,” Gwennap said. “But at the same time, this is kind of just marketing 101 for an American or European company.”
Renesas is making a huge push into the mobile space, Gwenapp said. The company has the potential to be a significant player based on the strength of the Nokia technology, he said, but the company lacks legacy products and key relationships that competitors already have.
“They are just at the very beginning of what they need to do become a major worldwide player in the market,” Gwenapp said. “They have a long way to go and it’s kind of late in the game for them to break in. 3G is pretty well set. What Renesas is hoping is that they can take advantage of the 3Gg to 4G transition to break into the market.”
Prior to acquiring the Nokia baseband unit, Renessas was becoming a bigger supplier to Nokia of other parts, primarily power amplifiers and RF transceivers, Strauss said. Renesas viewed the baseband acquisition as a way to solidify its relationship with Nokia and “get a bigger slice of the pie,” Strauss said. Acquiring the unit also gave Renesas the opportunity to market the technology to other customers besides Nokia, he said.
Mahoney said the Renesas Mobile spinout came out of the “100-day plan” developed by Renesas President Yasushi Akao, but that the company was not ready to disclose it until last week. During Renesas’ recent developers’ conference, Akao said that while some aspects of the 100-day plan had already been made public, other aspects would be forthcoming.
Renesas said that more than 75 percent of Renesas Mobile employees would be based outside of Japan.